discussion 1.22

Topic: We must introduce rental system of textbooks instead of free of charge.

disagree side:)
Lucy: If we introduce it, they will have some problems. For examples they can't bring out textbook at home, and draw under line to inportant points. So they can't study enough because of it.

Emiliy: Maybe some students wanna write some important points on textbooks. So if we introuce it, they don't come to write that.

Izabella: If we introduce it, they can't take a note and bring out textbooks at home. And teachers often says 'Take a note". So we shouldn't introduce it.

agree side:)
Sofy: Totall costs of textbooks will be so big. Some students are not afford to buy textbooks.

Sara: Cost of that is so big. And each school can get more high quality textbooks. Moreover they can forget that at home.

Questions and Answers.

Q1.What do you think about cost of it?
--->they should pay that by themselves in the future.
--->If we introduce it, they can save money, and we can give them more confortable place to study, buy computer, so like this we can use the money in other ways.

Q2. Why do you think more students can go to school if we introduce it?
--->At first, she thought we have to buy textbooks by ourselves, so she cancels that.

Q3 Disagree side said they can't take a memo.
--->If we introduce it,  they can concentrate on study to take a memo, but we should take a more detail memo by themselves.

4.We should change and buy textbooks every time that change.

5.Why don't you want to use other people's (used) textbooks?

6.If we intoduce it, it's good for ECO. Also they can concentrate on study and listen to carefully.
--->Without textbooks, it's hard to concentrate on studying by themselves. And teachers have to copy textbooks every times, give them handout.

Conclusion
We try to introduce it at trial periods in elementary school.
If we can't do well or not, we change this system case by case to improve it.


My comment
Students tend to rely on textbooks when they study, so I think by limiting times when they can take textbooks, they can study effectively and concentrate on study. Also if we think that we will introduce it for ECO, we should introduce not rental system, but tablet. In fact,  Korea introduces it in elementary school, so we should do I think. Also I can think we should rental textbooks in one year.
By doing that, they can bring out that at home, and whenever they want to study they can study without a class.In case of they lose that, they have to compensate that.